Uniqlo vs Everlane Cashmere: Crew, V-Neck, and the Price

Uniqlo and Everlane both sell a cashmere sweater women can wear under a coat. They do not sell the same knit. Uniqlo is the lighter, cheaper crew that pills at the elbow and still earns the price. Everlane is the heavier crew and the boyfriend shape, closer to a layer you keep. I compared them on the neckline, the weight, and what the price actually buys.

Cashmere is a fiber, not a promise. A thin Uniqlo crew can be real cashmere and still feel like a T-shirt by November. An Everlane crew uses more yarn and holds a shoulder. If the sweater collapses when you pinch the hem, it will collapse under a blazer. Pinch before you read the review.

cashmere sweater women v neck

The v-neck is the office neck. It shows a collar and a fine chain. Uniqlo's cashmere v-neck is shallow, so it works over a shirt without a gap at the sternum. Everlane's v is a little deeper and needs a camisole or a buttoned shirt if the office is formal. A deep v under an open coat looks unfinished. A shallow v under a blazer looks planned.

Crew is the default for a coat commute. V-neck is the default for a meeting. Buy the v only if you already own the crew, or if your coats are open. A turtleneck is a third shape and a warmer one. It is not a substitute for the v when the dress code wants a collar.

The black turtleneck in the photo is the warm end of the same fiber. It is useful as a check on weight. If your Uniqlo crew is thinner than this knit, it is a base layer, not the sweater you wear alone. Everlane's crew is closer to this density at the shoulder.

everlane cashmere crew

The Everlane cashmere crew is the one people search when they want a sweater that is not a logo. The shoulder is set, the hem hits the high hip, and the cuff is tight enough to show under a coat. The boyfriend version is longer and slouchier. Buy the crew if you wear it under a blazer. Buy the boyfriend if you wear it with jeans and no jacket.

Pilling shows at the underarm on both brands. Everlane's tighter knit pills later. Uniqlo's lighter knit pills first and can be shaved. A pilled Uniqlo is still cheaper to replace than a pilled Everlane. That is the real price comparison, not the tag on day one.

A heavier navy knit, the kind on the Vince cashmere sweater, sits above both on price and on hem. Vince is the v-neck you keep for a coat that is already good. Everlane is the crew you buy when Vince is more sweater than you need. Uniqlo is the spare.

cashmere sweater women uniqlo

Cashmere sweater women Uniqlo is the volume search because the price is the point. The women's crew is light, the colors rotate, and the fit is boxy in a small way. It layers under a wool coat without adding a lump at the hip. It does not hold a shape the way Everlane does when you take the coat off.

A fuzzier knit, like the pink sweater above, is a different hand. Cashmere should feel cool and fine, not plush like a teddy. If the Uniqlo piece feels plush, it may be a blend. Read the fiber line. 100 percent cashmere is the comparison. A wool blend is a different buy.

Under a long coat, weight matters more than the logo. The COS wool coat already has shoulder. A thin Uniqlo crew disappears under it. An Everlane crew can replace the coat indoors. Do not stack a boyfriend sweater under a padded shoulder.

Color is the last split. Uniqlo wins on the odd shade, the one you wear twice. Everlane wins on navy, black, and camel, the colors you wear weekly. A weekly color deserves the heavier crew. A twice-a-season color can be the cheaper crew.

Who should buy which. Buy Uniqlo if you want a real cashmere layer under a coat and you will replace it when it pills. Buy Everlane if the sweater is the outfit once the coat comes off. Skip both if you need a structured shoulder. That is a blazer, not a knit.

Questions before the knit

Is Uniqlo cashmere real cashmere?

The pieces labeled 100 percent cashmere are cashmere. They are spun lighter than Everlane's crew, so they feel less expensive because they are less yarn, not because the fiber is fake. Check the content line on the size tab.

Does the Everlane cashmere crew pill?

Yes, at the underarm and the cuff, later than Uniqlo. A tighter knit delays it. A bag strap will still raise the fiber. Shave it. Do not treat pilling as a reason to size up.

Should I buy the v-neck or the crew?

Crew for a coat and a closed front. V-neck for a shirt collar and a meeting. Uniqlo's v is shallower and safer. Everlane's v needs a layer if the neckline drops.

Which one works under a wool coat?

Uniqlo, because it is thinner at the hip and the cuff. Everlane's boyfriend length bunches under a belted coat. The crew from Everlane works if the coat is unstructured and you take it off indoors.

The buy is the yarn weight, then the neck, then the price. Uniqlo for the layer. Everlane for the sweater you wear alone. Navy and black on the heavier crew. The odd color on the lighter one.